Glenn

http://news.com.com/8301-10784_3-97...ag=2547-1_3-0-5


>>>>>>>>>>




Sen. Kerry wants to ban Internet images of dog fighting

It's time to add onetime presidential hopeful John Kerry to the long list of politicians who have scant understanding of free speech and the Internet.

Kerry, a Massachusetts Democrat, said in a press release on Friday that he wants to make it "illegal to transmit images of dog fighting, to run websites that cater to dog fighting."

Sen. Kerry wants to outlaw the 'transmission' of this image over the Internet.

Such a law could, of course, imperil news organizations and animal rights Web sites that "transmit images of dog fighting" as part of reporting on or, alternatively, condemning the practice. It could even make this article, which includes a photograph of dogs fighting, illegal.

Thanks a lot, senator.

Now we should say at this point that we're hardly fans of dogfighting, which is a brutal, bloody, and awful practice.

But neither are we fans of Washington politicians who fasten firmly onto a topic, like lamprey eels, immediately after it hits the headlines. As far as we can tell, Kerry is no longtime, principled opponent of dog fights: a Web search shows his first press release on the topic appeared two days after NFL star Michael Vick's indictment on dogfighting charges hit the news last week. Kerry, of course, has been in the U.S. Senate since 1985.

It's true that dog fighting is illegal in every state, at least according to the Humane Society of the United States. And a recently-amended federal law already bans interstate transport of any animal used in a "fighting venture."

But just because an act is illegal doesn't mean that photographs of it should be. Photographs of murders appear in documentaries and in news articles. Images of the My Lai massacre, in which U.S. soldiers slaughtered unarmed Vietnamese civilians, helped to end the Vietnam war. Should photographs of a college student using peer-to-peer networks to trade copyrighted files--a federal crime, no joke--be outlawed by the U.S. Congress as well?

Now, we recognize that the senator from Massachusetts could probably write legislation in such a way that would get a thumbs-up from the Supreme Court and not create another gaping hole in the First Amendment's shield protecting Americans from government censorship. (Something like: "No person, in order to promote a dog fighting event that is prohibited under state or federal law, shall knowingly post on the Internet videos showing dogs fighting at an organized match or competition...")

But Kerry's self-congratulatory press release gave no sign that he intended his harebrained scheme to be limited that way, and not giving politicians more credit for constitutional intelligence than they actually deserve should be a tenet of all political reporting.

Kerry, by the way, received a remarkably poor grade of just 15 out of 100 possible points in CNET News.com's 2006 Technology Voter Guide. That's in part because of his dogged support for other censorial measures over the years, including the unconstitutional Communications Decency Act, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act's "anti-circumvention" rules, and to place Internet filters in schools and libraries. At least he's consistent.

We should note, to avoid charges of partisan bias, that Kerryesque censor-happy proposals are hardly limited to Democrats. The Bush administration is no champion of civil liberties, and Republican politicians have recently floated ideas like forcing Web sites to report illegal images, requiring Internet providers to keep records on their users' activities and demanding that naughty Web sites be labeled.

__________________


My MYSPACE Page My Homepage: Glennmoller.com MWGC#2

Frito

He better get permission from Al Gore before he attempts that sh!t

__________________

stangxs

anyone have vids of pitbull fights? I've never seen one.

__________________

06 GT 475RWHP 437RWTQ

Joshness

Me > Kerry

__________________

Sign my Petition to End online Petitions!

ZQ8Dude

wtf?

__________________
"in a country of lost souls, rebellion comes hard. But in a religously oppressive city, which half it's popluation isn't even of that religion, it comes like fire."- Stevo

jpetre

People in the backgroud should be made to fight till death!

__________________
99 White Cobra / Tan Int. Gone 7-29-02
03 Mach 1 / Dark Interior Gone 6-02-07
07 Roush 427R Vista Blue / White Stripes

** 2008 Pearl White Ducati 848 **


"When God created roads, he painted an invisible line of perfection. Then He created Ducati motorcycles to follow it."

Pjk

Creep Quasimodo!

Yeah...I'm sure that "dogfight" ranks higher than pr0n in google image search.

__________________

ZQ8Dude

I dont see how you someone could watch that. Cock fighting is one thing with brainless birds...but a dog?

__________________
"in a country of lost souls, rebellion comes hard. But in a religously oppressive city, which half it's popluation isn't even of that religion, it comes like fire."- Stevo